The Blog

Ethical Consumerism

John Hayward   Posted: 24 June 2008

Keywords: Lifestyle Issues,

From the number of people I saw hauling huge Primark bags filled with clothes along Oxford Street today, their business does not appear to have been too seriously dented by last night's BBC Panorama programme exposing use of child labour by some of its suppliers in India.

To be honest, when the story appeared on Sunday night's Ten O'Clock News, along with news of the discount clothing store's pre-emptive response in sacking the three Indian factories, my immediate reaction was, "Another group of children who will now end up in prostitution or more abusive work environments..." It therefore comes as no surprise to me to learn that the retailer has been criticised on precisely this point by development charities working in the area. Its director, Breege O'Donoghue, has defended his actions by maintaining, “The relationship was broken.” However, that simply serves to underline again how "throw-away" relationships have become in the West. Our individualistic, consumer mentality tells us that if we don't feel personally satisfied by our circumstances and relationships, then we should get out and find alternative options that might better fulfil our individual needs.

No, if we claim to be ethical consumers in today's global village, then Western companies surely have a responsibility to retain and retrain suppliers that fail to meet our ethical standards? And that means each of us also has responsibilities:

  • as customers, to realise that the issues involved in trying to make "ethical" purchases are far more complex and interwoven than simply looking for the right brand, logo or kite mark;
  • as shareholders, to exercise what influence we can to promote greater awareness and engagement with the challenges facing our poorer global neighbours; and
  • as citizens, to question whether our choices and actions are socially and globally responsible, promote a climate of trust and hope, and encourage others to develop positive relationships in their families and communities.

Comments

Is Primark being unfairly treated in this: given their place on the high street and pricing policy. Most garments these days are made in the far east and I find it potentially more offensive if other retailers are charging more for garments that are costing the same to produce.

Ian Manzie   2 July 2008

I think it could be a positive thing that Primark reacted and sacked the 3 companies involved. Of course ideally they would put in place some help for the children but I hope that the signal has gone out to other Indian companies that this sort of child labour is not acceptable. Where are the politicians in all this? Surely they should be passing laws stopping this type of exploitation- countries like India and the West can also apply pressure and pass laws restricting trading conditions ina reas of the world where child labour exists.

colin johnson   3 July 2008

Comments

To post a comment on this blog simply enter your details below and click 'post comment' to continue. Note that your email will only be used to inform you if someone replies to this comment.

Name

Email address

Your comment

Enter text as it appears on the right

Image Verification