The Brexit election?

by Guy Brandon, 20th April 2017.

The news of a snap General Election came as a surprise to just about everyone, apparently including most government ministers, though more cynical readers might think it was a long-planned exercise. Having insisted there would be no election until 2020, Theresa May stated that she wanted to secure her mandate for Brexit, now that Article 50 has been triggered but before detailed negotiations have begun. At present, the Conservatives’ slim majority and divided approach to Europe mean that the process of leaving the EU would likely be beset with delays and complications.

Not a very ‘general’ election

In a General Election parties necessarily cover a wide range of issues as they seek to attract voters.

However, in the wake of a hugely controversial and divisive referendum, this election will inevitably be seen as a way to validate – or otherwise – the country’s decision to leave the EU, and specifically Theresa May’s realisation of that decision in the form of ‘Hard’ Brexit. Whatever promises are made in the parties’ hastily-drafted manifestos, all will pale into insignificance in comparison to their approach to that. It is a single-issue vote.

This makes it a General Election unlike any other, since suddenly party lines take a back seat. There are Conservatives who are pro-Remain and Labour MPs who are pro-Leave. Those Remainers who accept the Leave vote have strong opinions about the relationship that Britain should have with the EU, particularly in terms of freedom of movement.

Different choices

In every other election, people vote for their local MP with an eye on the big picture: which party they want to be in power overall. This time around, the big picture is different. The ultimate choice is not Conservative/Labour, or for any single party. It is essentially Hard Brexit/Alternative – where the alternative in question has yet to be decided or fully articulated. That raises the issue of tactical voting, of choosing an unwanted MP because he or she might help make up the numbers in parliament required to bring about a desired outcome. Does the Bible have anything to say about this unprecedented situation?

First and foremost, Christian voters must remember that God is sovereign – not Brussels, and not the UK government. Whatever the outcome, there is a broader narrative at work in British and world history.

Secondly, political engagement is about far more than voting. The biblical view of government was not one of top-down decision-making. It was about people being empowered to act at every level of society. The more the state tries to do, the less citizens feel the need to do. The antidote is to work actively to make the kind of society we want to live in, whatever colour(s) of government we end up with.

Finally, there may still be choices of candidate. If we are choosing between two candidates with the same approach to Brexit, there will be many other concerns to take into account, not least their approach to social justice. Whatever the outcome of the election, and whatever horse-trading goes on afterwards, we have a responsibility to try to choose well, and to hold those elected to account.

Share this post on your network

Category: Blogs

April, 2017

Comments (2)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. John says:

    So, does the Bible teach us to vote Conservative or Labour, right or left? Please come off the fence and answer this without a fudge. Actually, we all know that Christians tend to be Conservative because they have swallowed the polemic about the left being godless… But if you apply the social justice test you come up with a rather different answer. So basically it comes down to a simple question. Do Christians stand with the parties of privilege, self-interest, xenophobia and lies, or do they stand with those non-believers who nevertheless reflect some of Christ’s compassion and thirst for social justice?

    • u says:

      John, there are sincere Christians who are on both left and right – if you look up the Christians in Politics website you can find some great examples. We’ve also had members of the Labour and Lib Dems parties, as well as Conservative voters, on Jubilee Centre’s staff in the last year! It’s not our job to suggest how Christians should vote, but we hope to provide resources to help people think through issues biblically, and then decide for themselves which way to vote. We also recommend listening carefully to people on the ‘opposing’ side, because a biblical approach to politics will require developing relational skills such as finding acceptable compromise and building consensus.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.